Business Finance News

Government has not gone far enough on marketplace VAT

90,000 threshold leaves reform open to abuse warns Claritas Tax

Claritas Tax says the government has not gone far enough in its announced plans to make online marketplaces such as Amazon, eBay and Temu collect VAT on sales by UK sellers. Claritas Tax supports the principle but warns that a £90,000 threshold per platform would leave an avoidable loophole, allowing businesses to spread sales across marketplaces to stay below each platform’s collection threshold.

Stuart Brodie, VAT Partner at Claritas Tax, is calling for a nil threshold for marketplace VAT collection. Retaining a per-platform threshold risks building opportunities for abuse into the reform from the outset, weakening its ability to tackle avoidance and deliver fairer competition for compliant retailers.

Stuart Brodie, VAT Partner at Claritas Tax, comments:

“The government is moving in the right direction, but it has not gone far enough. Making marketplaces responsible for collecting VAT can strengthen compliance. Keeping a £90,000 threshold per platform, however, risks building a route around that responsibility into the very rules intended to tighten it.

“A compliant VAT-registered retailer should not be undercut by a competitor that fails to account for VAT when it should. Marketplace collection offers a way to address that unfairness and concentrate collection in a relatively small number of platforms, rather than leaving HMRC to pursue individual non-compliant traders. But the reform will fall short if businesses can arrange their sales to escape marketplace collection.

“Genuinely small businesses need proportionate rules. That does not justify a separate £90,000 collection threshold on every platform. A per-platform test creates an obvious incentive to spread sales across marketplaces, keeping each below the limit. Businesses could also seek to fragment activity between legal entities. The rules should close off those opportunities, not invite them.

“The answer is a nil threshold for marketplace VAT collection. That would remove the per-platform threshold loophole: spreading sales across platforms or splitting activity between entities would no longer keep those sales below a marketplace collection limit. It would also remove the need to monitor that limit. This is a call to remove the marketplace collection threshold, not to abolish the general VAT registration threshold. If the government retains a per-platform allowance, it risks handing those intent on avoidance a ready-made opportunity to exploit the reform.

“A nil marketplace threshold would not, on its own, solve every compliance problem. The government must also address the interaction with sales through traders’ own websites, so that tightening collection on platforms does not simply displace non-compliance elsewhere. But that is no reason to retain an avoidable loophole within marketplaces. The government should remove the per-platform threshold and make this reform count.”

Stuart is available for interviews and further comment today and over the coming days.