Business News

Why self-employed renters in the UK are still being penalised for not having a payslip

A person holding a small house and some money

Since 1 May 2026, landlords in England have had to give a valid reason if they want to end a tenancy. Section 21 is gone, fixed-term assured tenancies have been replaced by periodic ones and, where a landlord wants possession, one of the recognised grounds now has to apply.

It means the decision about who moves in carries more weight.

At the same time, more people are working for themselves. ONS figures show the number of self-employment jobs rose by 177,000, or 4.4%, in the three months to March 2026.

Yet much of tenant referencing still works best for someone with one employer, a fixed salary and three payslips ready to upload.

A workforce that’s stopped fitting the form

For most salaried workers, proving what they earn is fairly straightforward. Give the referencing company your employment details, show them your payslips and, assuming the numbers stack up, move on.

Self-employed income tends to require more explaining.

A freelancer might have a quiet January and an exceptionally good March. A company director could pay themselves through a combination of salary and dividends. A sole trader may have earned comfortably above the affordability threshold for years without ever receiving anything resembling a monthly payslip.

Goodlord’s latest State of the Lettings Industry report found that 7% of tenants surveyed were self-employed, against 72% in full-time employment. It’s hardly the majority, but it’s enough people to expose the limitations of a process largely designed around conventional employment.

Section 21 has made the decision at the start more important

Before May, landlords had the option of using Section 21 to regain possession without establishing fault on the tenant’s part. That route no longer exists.

There are still grounds on which a landlord can recover a property, including serious rent arrears and circumstances where they intend to sell. But the days of serving a no-fault notice are over.

It’s understandable, then, that some landlords and agents will be more cautious before handing over the keys.

A spokesperson for J Property Management, a London property management and lettings company, said the change has made the early stages of a tenancy more important for landlords.

“Landlords aren’t necessarily looking for the applicant with the most conventional job. They want to know that the rent is affordable and likely to be paid. The difficulty with self-employed applicants is that getting to that answer can take a little more work.

“Since the rules changed, there is understandably more focus on getting that decision right at the start. But a freelancer or business owner shouldn’t automatically be seen as a greater risk just because their income doesn’t arrive as the same figure on the same day every month.”

A salaried applicant earning £45,000 can be relatively easy to prove. Someone earning the same amount through freelance work may need considerably more paperwork, more checking and, in some cases, a guarantor.

The rent is the same. The way they prove they can afford it isn’t.

Being able to afford the rent and proving it are different things

Self-employed applicants can be asked for SA302 tax calculations, HMRC tax year overviews, an accountant’s reference or several months of bank statements. Exactly what’s required depends on the landlord, agent and referencing company.

For someone who has only recently started working for themselves, it can be harder again. They might be earning well now but not have two full years of accounts to show for it.

That matters in a rental market where applicants are often competing for the same property and landlords understandably don’t want homes sitting empty while paperwork is chased.

The quickest answer can be to ask for a guarantor.

That works if there’s a parent or relative who meets the criteria and is happy to take on the responsibility. Plenty of renters don’t have that option, regardless of what they earn.

The applicants getting stuck aren’t always the risky ones

Marco Laurence, founder of Rentmigo, a professional UK rent guarantor service, said his team regularly sees applicants caught in exactly that position.

“The applicants who get stuck aren’t usually the risky ones,” he said. “They’re the ones whose income doesn’t arrive in a shape referencing software recognises.

“We see self-employed people who could comfortably afford the rent asked for a guarantor purely because their proof of income looks different from a payslip, not because anyone doubts the number itself.

“Since Section 21 went, we’ve noticed landlords and agents asking harder questions before they commit to a tenancy, which makes sense on its own terms. But that’s exactly why the paperwork gap matters more now. If a good applicant gets filtered out at the referencing stage, that’s a cost to the landlord too, not just the tenant.”

Guarantors aren’t only for students anymore

The idea of needing a guarantor still tends to conjure up a student asking a parent to sign a form before moving into their first rented house.

The rental market is broader than that now.

Professional guarantor services are also being used by people who can afford their rent but don’t have somebody willing or able to guarantee it personally. That includes overseas renters, people without family in the UK and self-employed applicants whose income doesn’t pass through referencing as neatly as a salary would.

For a landlord, it means they don’t have to relax their affordability requirements. For the tenant, it can mean the difference between an awkward referencing process and losing the property altogether.

But the growing use of guarantors also points to a wider issue.

There are millions of self-employed people in Britain, alongside freelancers, contractors and company directors whose earnings don’t necessarily arrive as the same amount on the same date each month. As that group grows, landlords and agents are going to see more applicants whose finances are perfectly sound but can’t be summed up with three payslips.

Tenant referencing hasn’t quite caught up with that yet. And with the rental system itself having just undergone its biggest change in years, there is a good argument that it should.