Scotland

Water sector cannot build its way to resilience while ageing tanks go unchecked, warns expert after Glasgow congress.

a bridge over a large body of water

A leading structural repair expert has warned the UK cannot build its way to resilience while ageing tanks go unchecked.

Roger Line believes the condition of existing concrete assets must form a central part of the resilience debate, as the regulator links 17 water quality failures to structural defects.

Mr Line, the founder and CEO of Structural Repairs, was speaking after attending the IWA World Water Congress and Exhibition at Glasgow’s SEC earlier this month, where thousands of delegates from around the world met under the banner of water resilience.

“Resilience was the word on everyone’s lips in Glasgow, and much of the conversation was about what the sector builds next,” he said. “But the network we rely on today is the one already in service. You can’t plan resilience around assets you haven’t properly looked at.”

His warning comes as the Drinking Water Inspectorate’s latest annual report attributed 47 drinking water quality events in England in 2025 directly to poor asset health or plant failure.

Seventeen of those were structural failures affecting treatment works, treated water tanks or service reservoirs. The regulator described ingress into these structures as a recurrent and preventable risk.

England’s public water supply relies on 989 treatment works and 3,626 service reservoirs, according to the inspectorate. In written evidence to the House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee’s inquiry into climate adaptation, Water UK has called for faster approvals for new infrastructure and new resilience standards, arguing that extra capacity would give companies more time to restore services when critical assets fail.

Mr Line said new capacity matters, but must sit alongside a closer look at existing structures.

“A concrete tank can look serviceable from the outside, but that doesn’t tell you where the reinforcement is, whether there are voids or deterioration, or what’s causing a leak and how far it goes,” he said. “If you can answer those questions early, you can turn an urgent reaction into a planned intervention.”

He said the global conversation in Glasgow now had to translate into local, asset-by-asset work.

“The ideas travel well, but the fix never does. Every tank has its own history, its own exposure and its own operating constraints. You have to establish its condition and decide what it actually needs.”

That starts with question-led investigation, combining visual survey, ground-penetrating radar and targeted material testing, he said, with each method chosen for what it can and cannot reveal.

“Scanning tells you things a surface inspection can’t, but it hasn’t repaired anything. Diagnosis and delivery are different stages and they need different evidence. Filling a visible crack or applying a new finish shouldn’t be confused with dealing with the cause.”

Mr Line said operating realities had to shape every repair plan.

“Access, isolation, water quality protection, curing conditions and return-to-service requirements all need building in from the start. A method that looks good on paper might not suit the shutdown window you’ve actually got. And the evidence you’ll need afterwards should be agreed before work begins. A before-and-after photo is no substitute for acceptance criteria.”

He called for condition evidence on existing structures to be weighed alongside the case for new capacity.

“Ofwat’s asset-health work is a step in the right direction. The next step is making sure robust condition evidence on structures like service reservoirs sits alongside decisions on new capacity, not after them. Where keeping an asset is technically right, it preserves useful infrastructure and avoids some of the disruption of replacement.

“Glasgow showed the sector is serious about resilience. Looking after the structures already in service has to be part of that ambition, not an afterthought.”