For individuals with interests in family-owned or privately held trading businesses, the recent changes which limit the availability of Business Property Relief (BPR) mean that it is more important than ever to understand the value of assets held. This could be to inform strategic decision making or simply to ensure that sufficient funds are available to settle future inheritance tax (IHT) liabilities when they arise.
Tax valuations are complex and require a thorough understanding of the legislative framework and underlying case law. This is an area where we expect continued and increasing scrutiny from HMRC’s Shares and Assets Valuation (SAV) team, making robust, comprehensive valuation advice essential to supporting positions taken and reliefs claimed.
Family businesses and the IHT funding challenge
For family-owned businesses, IHT planning presents a distinct set of challenges. Although BPR can, in many cases, significantly reduce or eliminate IHT exposure, careful consideration of qualifying conditions is important from the outset, and changes in business activity, asset composition, or ownership structure can affect eligibility over time.
For many business owners, shareholdings which were previously expected to be 100% relieved by BPR may no longer be covered, with relief limited to 50% for qualifying business property worth in excess of £2.5 million. As a result, shareholdings previously expected to pass free of IHT may now give rise to a material tax liability.
Prudent planning is often required to assess how an IHT liability could be funded when it arises, whether on death or as a consequence of a ten-year charge in a trust.
Given that private company shares are often illiquid, this can present a significant practical challenge.
In response, many shareholders are revisiting their approach to extracting value from their businesses. Strategies may include the implementation of dividend policies, reorganisation of share capital or partial realisations over time. These decisions must also take account of wider commercial and succession planning considerations and the potential impact on other stakeholders, particularly where funds are required by only one shareholder or their estate.
Valuation plays a central role, helping to quantify tax risk and inform funding decisions.
Market Value
For UK tax purposes, transfers between connected parties—such as trustees and family members—are treated as occurring at Market Value, regardless of any consideration actually paid.
The definition of Market Value for tax purposes requires the valuer to envisage a hypothetical transaction between anonymous participants on the open market.
However, care is essential to capture the correct value: transfers for IHT purposes are assessed by reference to the ‘loss to the estate’ and different aggregation rules apply for both capital gains tax (CGT) and IHT purposes. An incorrect assumption or oversimplification can result in very different conclusions.
HMRC scrutiny
We anticipate that IHT valuations will be a key area of focus for SAV following the changes to the legislation.
At the recent SAV Forum, a representative confirmed that the team has already seen a significant increase in valuation work via trust returns, reflecting that many taxpayers made changes to their affairs ahead of the rules changing in April 2026. SAV’s expectation is that their caseload in this area will continue to increase, with HMRC allocating additional staffing resource in response.
At the same time, wider changes to the IHT regime, including the treatment of unused pension funds within estates, are likely to increase both the complexity and the overall tax exposure for many taxpayers. This creates a clear dynamic in which taxpayers may seek to support lower valuations, while HMRC will wish to ensure that values are appropriately evidenced and justified.
There is no mechanism to proactively agree IHT valuations with HMRC. Taxpayers must submit trust and probate returns based on their own assessment of value and wait to see whether HMRC raise any queries.
Against this backdrop, the quality of valuation support is critical. HMRC applies a rigorous review process and expects submissions to be thorough, well-supported and technically robust. While instructing a professional valuer is not mandatory, it is strongly recommended. Valuations should demonstrate a clear understanding of the facts and context, supported by a level of analysis proportionate to both the value involved and the associated tax risk.
Conclusion
Valuations are not simply a compliance requirement; they are a fundamental aspect of effective wealth planning. In the context of family businesses, good valuation advice underpins key decisions around succession, tax and liquidity.
With the changes to BPR resulting in reduced reliefs and increased HMRC scrutiny, the need for robust, defensible, and well-documented valuations has never been greater. Addressing valuation issues early, and with the appropriate level of technical rigour, is essential to achieving outcomes that are both tax-efficient and resilient under HMRC scrutiny.
